How To Cook Frozen Pizza In Toaster Oven

How To Cook Frozen Pizza In Toaster Oven?

Figuring out the right way how to cook frozen pizza in a toaster oven is something many people struggle with. If you don’t do it right, it might come out mushy, which can be a great disappointment.

One thing you should know about using a toaster oven for cooking pizza is that you should find a way to fit your pizza in the oven. If you have a compact toaster oven, you will have to cut your pizza to fit in. This becomes a problem if it is not frozen.

The crust of the delicacy helps to make sure that the toppings are in place. The toppings will melt over the edges when you cut them before cooking them.

If you put it in a tray below, it will catch the overflowing toppings. However, the bottom part will not be crispy because the tray will act as an insulator.

Here are the instructions to help you prepare this delicious treat in a toaster oven.

@humphreyhours Super aesthetic frozen pizza making #chef #gourmet #aesthetic #toasteroven #influencer #notspon ♬ Escapism. – Super Sped Up – RAYE

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.

Can You Cook Frozen Pizza In Toaster Oven?

Yes, you can not only reheat your pizza but also cook frozen pizza in your toaster oven. It may sound like a complex project at first, but it is as straightforward as it gets.

Please keep reading to learn how it is done.

How To Cook Frozen Pizza In Toaster Oven?

It is important to note that defrosting is not necessary in this case.

  1. Preheat your toaster oven to the highest temperature it can go. Give it 10+ minutes if you have a big unit or 5 minutes if your oven is small.
  2. Unpack your frozen pizza. Make sure to remove all plastic – molten plastic does not add to the flavor.
  3. Place your pizza in the oven without a tray or foil or anything that could block the direct heat. Make sure hot air can flow under the pizza. Put it as close to the top part as possible so it can get enough heat.
  4. Check on the pizza after approximately 5-7 minutes because it tends to cook fast. However, the exact time differs from one oven to another.
  5. When the pizza is ready, most of the cheese in the middle will be light brown in color. You can take your pizza out and prepare to enjoy it.

Tips and Tricks

Some tips and tricks will help you get the best results when making pizza in a toaster oven. Here we go.

Put pizza directly in the oven

Avoid using a pan, baking tray, aluminum foil, or anything that will prevent it from getting direct heat if you want it to cook fast and come out golden brown and crispy. The heat should directly come in contact with the food.

Cut the pizza while frozen

If your oven is big enough to accommodate your pizza, you don’t have to cut it. If the oven is small, you have no option but to cut your pizza. Also, you may choose to cut it if you don’t plan on eating all of it at once. You can save the rest to eat later.

Some people find it soggy if they cook all of it at once, so they prefer to cut it. Others say that it cooks evenly when cut into slices.

If you decide to split the pizza, you must do it while it’s frozen. If you cut it after it has thawed, the cheese and other toppings will start to overflow, and you will have made a mess.

how to cook frozen pizza in a toaster oven

Use a solid knife for cutting

Now that we’ve established that you need to cut the delicacy while frozen, how do we go about it? Just like any other food, it is harder when frozen. Therefore, not any knife will do.

This is why you need a sharp kitchen knife or pizza cutter for the job.

Cut it on a firm surface

You need a firm surface for cutting it. Open the original packaging and get to work. You don’t need to use a plate. The box and cardboard under the treat will hold it in place.

A hard and flat surface will ensure it does not slide or move.

Apply pressure on the knife while cutting

Frozen pizza is hard. However, it doesn’t mean you should apply too much pressure on it while cutting. Cut it slightly and then exert pressure on the top part of the knife. It will just slide in easily.

If you do this, you will get a clean slice compared to when you put a lot of pressure on the knife before getting a good cut.

Get A Smart oven

If you are often cooking meals from frozen products, you should consider getting a Smart Oven like Breville BMO870BSS Review with Smart Defrost and From Frozen modes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you put frozen pizza directly in the oven?

Yes, you can put a frozen pizza directly in the toaster oven. Actually putting the pizza directly on the oven rack in the right way to cook the frozen pizza. You just have to be ready to clean the molten cheese from the bottom surface of your oven.

Can you cook a frozen pizza in a cardboard box?

No, you should not cook frozen pizza in cardboard. The cardboard can potentially catch fire. Most pizza boxes have colorful prints containing chemicals that will release when heated which may be dangerous. Always remove the cardboard before placing the pizza in the toaster oven for a safe and delicious result.

How To Cook Frozen Pizza In Toaster Oven


You will learn how to cook frozen pizza in the toaster oven when you practice these steps a few times. Once you master this, your work will become more enjoyable.

This is because a toaster oven makes work easier and cooks faster. You may find yourself eliminating other cooking appliances.

Pizza is delicious, and you can easily prepare it in your kitchen. What you need to keep in mind is cutting it while frozen if you want to. This will prevent it from running as opposed to when you do it when it has thawed. Also, avoid using trays to get that crustiness at the bottom.

With these steps, you can always prepare this delicious treat for yourself and your family.

All the best as you put this into practice.